Cash App vs. Venmo vs. Zelle – Who’s The Best?

Who’s the best? Cash App vs. Venmo vs. Zelle. Let’s explore that in this post.
Unlike other payment apps, Venmo has a touch of a social media feature in it. Upon creating an account on Venmo, you have the option to sync your account to your contacts and Facebook friends. 

When you connect your Facebook, it allows your friends to view your transactions. They can see to whom you’re sending money or who paid you.

The social media aspect in Venmo also lets your friends see memos that contain why you are paying or why you are receiving money.

While this feature adds a bit of a unique and fun concept to payment apps, it can also be a disadvantage. You may not be comfortable sharing details of your transaction with your friends.

There are other options for payment service apps like Zelle or Cash App for those concerned with privacy issues.  [as a sidenote: we actually signed up with Step Card for our teenager as an alternative to the Greenlight card and have been extremely satisfied with it].

Cash App vs. Venmo vs. Zelle
Cash App vs. Venmo vs. Zelle

Cash App and Venmo Have Debit Cards

If you want to transact through peer-to-peer payment systems while having your debit card, Cash App and Venmo offer that.

The debit cards offered by these two P2P apps connect your account balance to them. Simply, it does not connect to your checking account. You transact with it like you would with a bank debit card to transfer, pay and withdraw.

However, since your physical cash cards connect to your Cash App or Venmo account, make sure you have enough money to use for transactions. If you attempt to pay that exceeds your balance, you may pay overdraft fees.

Related: How to add money to your Cash App card?

Zelle Puts Money in Your Account Instantly

Cash App vs. Venmo vs. Zelle Continued…

Venmo and Cash App let you keep money in your account balance, while Zelle does not store it in your account. 

Zelle does not keep a balance because the funds you receive from the app transfer directly to your bank account. 

This setup is a good thing. Compared to Venmo and Cash App, Zelle provides a more convenient and cheaper way to receive payments.

Venmo and Cash app charge fees if you need the money rush transferred to your bank account. If you do not want to pay the fees, you have to wait for at least a day or two before receiving it.

Another thing to mention, the money kept in Venmo or Cash App does not passively grow. Meaning, keeping the money in these apps will take out the chance to earn from interest.

Because Zelle directly transfers money to your bank account, the funds stored can grow from banks’ interest. It gives you the option to make money passively.

Related: How does Venmo make their money?

Access Zelle Without The App

You can access Zelle by downloading its mobile app, but there is another direct way to use it.

If your credit union or financial institution offers Zelle in their services or apps, then you can access Zelle through their online banking. You can also check if it is available in their mobile app.

An example of a financial institution that offers this convenience is First Alliance Credit Union. Not only can you use Zelle by logging into online banking, but they also have it on their mobile app.

Cash App, Venmo, And Zelle All Are Safe

You may be wondering how safe electronic payments are. Security issues are possibly the top concern of people who are using or planning to use these apps.

Which of these three peer-to-peer payment apps is the most secure and safest? According to this article by Consumer Reports, Cash App, Venmo, Zelle, and other P2P payments are generally safe, but users still need to be careful of the possible risks.

Fraudsters are rampant in this space, especially if they are knowledgeable of the technology. These people may come up with schemes that they can use to lure you into paying them.

Sad to say that despite the upgrades in the safety issues, there’s still no 100% guarantee that you get the money scammed from you. In this situation, you have to be cautious of the people you are transacting with while using P2P payment apps.

Cash App vs. Venmo vs. Zelle — at least you can feel comfortable that they are all safe.

Related: How to Transfer my money from Venmo to the Cash App?

Zelle Is Free at First Alliance Credit Union

While these three apps serve the same purpose, they also have specific differences in their features. It’s only a matter of personal liking whether you’ll be more comfortable with Cash App, Venmo, or Zelle.

You have to consider if you are fine sharing details of your transaction to the public, you want to have a physical cash card, or if you can wait up for the delay before your payment reaches your bank account.

Trying out which works best for you may be tough but if you are not yet sure which app is suitable for you, try Zelle for free if you are a First Alliance Credit Union member. 

It is available for members of the union and accessible using their online banking and mobile app. The process is easy to understand, convenient, and transfers money quickly on your account.

Disclosure:  this article might contain links to the resources discussed.
Some of the links are affiliate links, meaning that I will make a small commission if you purchase a product or service by using the link. You get the same price whether you use our special link or not, and sometimes I’m able to get you an even better deal through my relationships!  More info in my privacy policy.

Brooks Conkle

Brooks Conkle

Brooks is an Entrepreneur, Sponge, Father, Husband, & Follower of the Golden Rule. He has over 15 years of experience as an entrepreneur after graduating with a BSBA in Finance from Auburn University. He’s addicted to growing new business ideas and any food that includes chocolate and peanut butter. Brooks is a firm believer in creating multiple streams of income and creates content here on BrooksConkle.com to help other hustlers in the areas of marketing, online business, personal finance, and real estate. 

Related Posts

Step Card Review – Why We Switched From Greenlight

Step Card Review – Why We Switched From Greenlight

Have a teenager, and you're wondering the best way to teach them about money? You can use all of the examples and pictures that you want. But like everything else in life, the best way to learn is through real-life experience. We signed up for the Greenlight Card in...

Why Is College Important? Here Are 10 Reasons

Why Is College Important? Here Are 10 Reasons

Your parents might be pushing you towards higher education. So why is college important anyway?  Sure, It might be nerve-wracking to graduate from high school and consider going to college. It’s easy to tell yourself that your classmates know everything and that...

Listen to Destroy the Box Podcast Below

Want To See My 19 Income Streams?

 I'll also share 100+ money-making ideas!

Nice! Now Go Confirm Your Email Address! (check promotion tab if a Gmail user)

Share This